Networking science.

The Swiss Young Academy networks young researchers from a wide range of scientific disciplines and creates an inspiring environment for inter- and transdisciplinary exchange and innovative ideas. Its members are the representatives of Swiss science and are regarded as the young voice of the Swiss Academies of Arts and Sciences.

Challenging Inequalities and Precarious Working Conditions in Swiss Academic Institutions

Background

Across the globe, Higher Education has undergone dramatic changes. The relationship of knowledge, research and teaching, the organisation of research institutions, and their financing and place in society have become a site of conflicting debates (Thwaites and Pressland 2017, Athelstan et al. 2011). Universities increasingly have to prove their ‘worth’ by quantifiably measurable contributions to the economy and society. Critical scholars have highlighted that universities have aligned themselves with neoliberal agendas that include precarious labour conditions, especially affecting people in already unstable economic and social positions (Ahmed 2012, Pereira 2016, Sifaki 2016, Taylor and Lahad 2018). The neoliberalization of academia has taken various forms across Europe. In some contexts, higher education has been quasi-privatized, with institutions competing for the high-paying student consumer, while in other contexts, governments have established a competitive funding landscape for their public universities. The increasing importance of university rankings, student numbers and competitive funding has coincided with an increase of administrative positions steeped in managerial discourses, introducing utilitarian output-oriented processes and structures (Taylor and Lahad 2018, Sifaki 2016).

 

Academic performance and excellence are increasingly measured in a quantitative fashion. Due to the growing disproportion between graduates and permanent faculty positions, especially junior academics and PhD students experience the increasing competition and pressure to perform, and feel the consequences for their career, quality of work, personal life, mental health, and overall research culture. Applied metrics may include finishing a PhD in a set timeframe, publishing a set number of papers per year, or securing external funding. The term ‘early career researcher’ (ECR), usually referring to scholars up to five years after the PhD phase, has been critiqued, because it implies a normative, streamlined career trajectory (Taylor and Lahad 2018). Research has often benefited from cross-disciplinary career transitions, experiences in other institutions and workplaces as well as exchanges between scholars from diverse backgrounds. We are using the term strategically, to draw attention to the particular challenges faced by PhD students and PostDocs in the first years after obtaining their PhD, while acknowledging that these challenges persist beyond this threshold in today's academic system.

 

ECRs, who are part of socially marginalised groups are particularly vulnerable to the logics of the neoliberal university as they additionally face discrimination. Feminist and anti-racist theorists have further highlighted that university gender and diversity initiatives often play on the emancipatory language of the feminist, queer and anti-racist movements while at the same time resisting real trans- formation and ignoring class and economic factors (Ahmed 2012, 2017, Taylor and Lahad 2018). While there is a lack of data about the lived experiences of minority scholars and ECRs at Swiss universities, international research shows that structural inequalities around race, class, ability, sexuality and gender can negatively affect career progression (Tate 2014, Taylor and Lahad 2018, Gutiérrez-Rodríguez 2016).

 

Goals

Institutions of higher education and research are sources of innovation, sites of education and training of tomorrow’s citizens and experts, and places to identify, study, and discuss new developments in societies. Swiss universities strive to be global leaders in research and education, and to attract diverse talents from around the world. The SYA fosters exchange among early career researchers to contribute to shaping the future of Swiss academia. This ambition is at the core of one of the first SYA joint projects, as is Challenging Inequalities and Precarious Working Conditions in Swiss Academic Institutions.

 

The project aims to shape and improve the Swiss academic environment and culture of tomorrow by:

  • supporting the creation of a self-sustained and transformative network for ECRs affected by racism and classism, enabling a debate about institutional discrimination and a space for peer support
  • fostering constructive exchange and networking between ECRs and stakeholders in Swiss research and education policy making
  • drawing attention to the issues and policy changes proposed
  • making knowledge on academic positions in Switzerland more available, democratising access to Swiss academia
  • contributing to a consensual change of institutions and careers in higher education

 

The 2022 project follows up on the learnings from the first joint project in 2021. In order to challenge the identified problem areas Universities as Employers, Working Conditions, Equity, Internationality and Participation by putting the devised policy changes in action:

Suggestions in English  /  Propositions en Francais  /  Vorschläge auf Deutsch


Share
Project group

Boulila Stefanie
Bovet Alexandre
Eeftens Marloes
Mueller Lucas
Posholi Lerato

Speaker
Retreat "Creating a Network for ECRs Affected by Racism and Classism" (29-31 August 2022)